Drywall vs. plaster: what’s the difference and which is better for your home?

Post Main Image

Both drywall and plaster have their place in residential construction. Whether you're restoring a heritage home or building new, understanding the pros and cons of each will help you choose the right fit for your walls and your lifestyle.

Comparing materials: strength, cost, and style

  1. Drywall is lighter, faster to install, and more cost-effective
  2. Plaster is dense, long-lasting, and offers a timeless finish
  3. Drywall gives clean modern lines ideal for new builds
  4. Plaster is better suited to curved surfaces and intricate details
  5. Drywall is easier to modify or repair in the future
  6. Plaster can add soundproofing and fire resistance, but at a higher cost
Choosing between drywall and plaster depends on your priorities: timeline, finish, budget, or tradition. We can walk you through the trade-offs.

Both materials can shine when used with intention. The right choice depends on your home’s design, age, and goals.

What to expect for resale and upkeep

The material you choose has long-term implications. Drywall tends to attract modern buyers looking for low maintenance and future flexibility. Plaster appeals to character home buyers but may carry higher upkeep costs. Know what your market values before committing.

  • Plaster walls may increase charm, but scare off buyers concerned about cost
  • Drywall is seen as standard in most modern builds
  • Insurance costs and repair quotes vary depending on the material
  • Routine damage is easier to fix on drywall
  • Plaster requires expertise for restoration or patching

Drywall: speed, repairability, and clean modern lines

Drywall is the go-to for fast, affordable construction. It delivers smooth, clean surfaces with minimal labor and is easy to patch or modify later. If your focus is modern aesthetics and practicality, drywall is likely the better fit.

Plaster: classic character, labor intensity, and longevity

Plaster excels in historic homes or luxury builds where detail and substance matter. It’s thicker, more durable, and often hand-applied, which increases both time and cost. For homeowners who value timeless texture and acoustic benefits, plaster may be worth it.

Still unsure which material is right for your space? Contact Truline Drywall for a tailored consultation. We’ve worked on everything from sleek new builds to detailed restorations. Let us help you choose the right wall system for lasting beauty and performance.

Related

Similar Articles